Tunnel vision

Posted by on Jan 13, 2012 in Blogging, Business Talks, Crochet, Designs, Knit | 11 comments

I’ll be the first to admit that being a knitwear designer rocks. It’s a fun, creative job, full of different tasks that allow you to keep your fingers in many different jam jars – which also makes boredom an impossible, almost forgotten feeling. You see your name in print (ego boost!), people talk about you and your designs on the internet, and you can even get free yarn. (I call it material testing, like a pastry chef, I need to check those cupcakes before I commit to them, yes… that’s what I call it)

You come up with an idea, a good one, and like in a movie, the spotlight shines on it. There’s nothing but bright, white light surrounding your idea and the light cheers you on until the garment is done and the pattern is released. Pure unadulterated joy.

Then again, there’s other things that make this job I chose the worst choice for me. There’s artist’s block. There’s having to do what you have to do when you don’t want to do it. Some call it procrastination, but in me, it’s mostly laziness.

I’m a sensitive person. This goes hand in hand with self-doubt and inability to make a decision when required to do so because of fear of choosing the wrong path. Sensitivity makes it also very hard to look at things objectively, especially when it comes to rejection.

As far as I have experienced, there’s 3 kinds of rejections -

- The ones that you never hear from again (like the boyfriend that never called again… I pretend they never got the call or fell down a manhole on the street, easier for my soul).

- The ones where you get all your materials back, crumpled in an envelope, saying “thanks but no thanks” (ouch)

- And the email type – like the above but with even less of a reason for the rejection

There’s the time when rejection is the ONLY thing coming your way. Black clouds come easy: Have I chosen the wrong career? Did I do anything wrong? Is my knitting not up to scratch? Do they think I’m ages away from being “good enough” for them?

Sometimes, when the rejected idea makes its way back to me and I can look at it in the cold light of day and say “yes… what on Earth were you thinking”. Other times, I can’t find the reasons. When this is the case, I tend to keep these ideas in a folder and re-visit them. Sometimes I reject them altogether and pretend it all happened in a lobotomy kind of day, and other times I make a couple of changes, improve the sketch and description and funnily enough, another publisher thinks that piece will be great for them.

A part of me never quite left school, and thinks that every single rejection will mount up to my final grade. After all, if I were in art school and my ideas were deemed “not artistically related to the topic” I’d fail, right? Competition, much like in art, is stiff. There’s many designers, some professionals whose food depends on their earnings (read – myself) and others who simply play at it on the side of a full-time job. This makes the need to get the gig much more urgent – I understand there’s guys doing this for fun but my roof depends on my making money, so it’s impossible not to take it personally when your idea is rejected.

It’s taken a while for me to learn that the less time I pick on myself about a rejection, the sooner I’ll be back in full swing trying out new ideas, or transforming those rejections into a successful self-published pattern as I’ve done before.

I’ve also found that I need to tone down some things to get acceptances. Certain publications seem to think less-is-more and I kept, stubborn, sending my out-of-this-world ideas to them – hence the rejection. I’ve point-blank refused to send submissions to certain places too, given that I’ve tried everything under the sun to get in and all of them have been dismissed – it’s a 99%-sure fact we simply don’t fit, so dust off my shoulders, I move along.

Why am I rambling about all this?

I’ve a submission in my hands. I’m thinking about it. Overly thinking about it. It’s swatched. It’s sketched. It’s (more or less) laid out to be sent off.

And I’m AFRAID.

I looked at it this morning and the thought popped into my head…

“they are going to hate it”

I can’t get that thought out of my head. I’ve done laundry. I’ve been out and froze my head to death in the winter chill, I’ve had a coffee, I’ve had a walk, I’ve marveled at the frost on top of the gardens this morning. And I still think I’m not going to send it through, because at the moment, I don’t think I can face it.

Remember the spotlight I spoke of before? This idea is the opposite. Like a tunnel, I’m in. Instead of a bright white light I can only see darkness surrounding my idea, and I somehow cannot make it shine.

It may be a great idea in my head – is it the physical translation that’s not working?

Bad yarn? Bad sketch? Bad stitching?

Or is it just me? I may have woken up 2 seconds too late today, I may be out of touch today and the darkness is just, well, a lack of a feeling. I’ll wake up tomorrow and it’ll be gone. But tomorrow it’ll be too late, out of deadline for submissions.

Do I send it in, feeling it’s not my best? Do I put it in the rejected pile, waiting to re-discover it? I’ve until bedtime to make up my mind, but this exercise made me think of the most important question of all – will this questioning of my abilities ever go away?

Print Friendly
  • Kate Oates

    send. it. in.

  • http://woollythinker.wordpress.com/ woollythinker

    Ok. So this may not feel true right now, but: you have nothing to lose. Send it in. Best case: you get in! Affirmation! Yay! Worst case: you don’t get in – ie. you’re exactly where you are now.

    Rejection hurts, yes, but *it’s not personal*. You don’t even have to deal with the fear of face-to-face rejection; it comes by email or post, you can take the blow in private, with tea. And the thing is, the really really big true thing that you have to learn: IT’S NOT PERSONAL. Sorry for shouting. But I’ve worked in publishing enough to really know this to be true. “No” doesn’t mean “not good enough” – it just means “we can’t use this right now”. It means: this doesn’t fit with what we’re trying to do for this issue; or, we have too much to get in; or, wow, we really wanted to use this but there’s a clash with something else here…

    Okay, sometimes it means not good enough. But you already know you’re a good designer. You have had enough designs published, and seen enough appreciation of your self-published designs, that you know you are good. So if your submission comes back and you don’t have that insight, “hm, that was never going to work”, you need to remind yourself that there are a whole heap of reasons that your really great design didn’t make it in that magazine, that one time. If you still like it, submit it somewhere else or self-publish. Nothing to lose. So really: what are you afraid *of*?

  • Elizabeth GM

    All of my instincts scream to send it in. I tend to be a what-have-I-got-to-lose kind of person, but in this case, I think the attitude is warranted. If you didn’t already have a stable of beautiful designs out there, then you would want to feel absolutely 100% certain about sending out this design. But even if — and this is a highly unrealistic worst-case scenario — the recipient deems this particular design poor, they wouldn’t think you were a poor designer. Why? Because you have such an accomplished track record already.

    All of that said, I share your waves of nagging self-doubt. It’s a hard business putting all of your creative self into a yarnie thing and then sending it off for judgment.

  • http://twitter.com/traceyselingo Tracey Selingo

    You are an artist, my dear. A kick-ass, talented, top-notch artist.

    Should the questioning ever go away? No, and it won’t, because (cue the choir) you care. Every idea you dream up, every pattern you make, every stitch, every thought, every ounce of your soul goes into your work. Questioning keeps you on your toes, makes you reach higher and dream bigger.

    The doubt, however, has no place in your world. Get rid of it. Ignore it. Take an empty jar, put a lid on it and keep it by your side. Stick a label on there with the word doubt. Let that be your reminder that doubt is an empty, useless, fear-feeding monster, that it’s contained in the jar so it can’t creep into your world.

    Stop questioning your brilliance. Get your submission in the mail. Because for all the walking and thinking and coffee drinking you’re doing over this only one this is for sure: you will never know unless you try.

    And if you get rejected? Move on and let it go.

  • Corrina / PicnicKnits

    Definitely send it in. And move on to the next thing. I think sometimes as designers we spend so much time agonizing over things that we waste valuable time that could be used to create the next great thing. Your portfolio is stunning – send it in – and say next!

  • http://twitter.com/tastefldiversns Laura Lynch Yona

    First off, you are a wonderful, inspirational designer. Your designs are lovely and clever and not at all run-of-the-mill, not to mention well-written with very clear instructions. Dude, you rock. 

    As far as sending something off and thinking they’ll hate it, my touchstone is always “do I love it enough to self-publish it if it gets rejected?” If the answer is “yes” then I send it in, because in my mind it’s already been “accepted” — I’m just giving someone else a chance to get involved with my awesomeness. Of course, I’m just barely starting out, so that may change. So far it seems to work for me, though.

  • http://twitter.com/Knitsophrenic Kate

    I once heard a story from a pretty popular designer how she just keeps moving her submissions around form one Magazine, to a yarn company, to a book, to another magazine. When they came back, the submissions were checked to make sure they were in good shape and put in the pile to be sent out again. One year, after submission were accepted and samples complete prominent yarn company A asked why prominent yarn company B got all the good designs… The designer laughed and said, “You rejected all those designs before I sent them over there….” 

    Some times I save the call for submissions and compare it to the final issue and they look nothing alike, and my submissions were rejected. My submissions were what was asked for… Then I asked an editor who explained, “I have to put out an issue of 24 cohesive designs, I have to take what I can get in the allotted amount of time, I pick the designs that look the best together” Ever since then Mood boards make me laugh…  

    So remember,  very often your submissions are wonderful, don’t throw them away. There are a zillion factors that go into publishing your design, unfortunately your skill and talent has very little to do with it.  Just send them on to another publication or yarn company…. 

    If you send it in, you have a chance they might take it, if you don’t send it in there is a 100% change all they will take it…. 

     

  • CambriaW

    This is such a powerful post, with powerful comments (and I read every single one of them).  I’m often in the same boat and I swore off submitting to anyone after three rejections last year.  But I did what many of the comment’s said, and I offered a pattern that was rejected by Twist Collective to a yarn company and they snatched it up!  I got to do my design.  I was paid.  And now the design is popular and it has it’s own knit-a-long group on Ravelry.  When I looked at the Twist issue after it’s release, I realized that it wasn’t me…the design just didn’t fit cohesively with the rest of the collection and I understood why they couldn’t use it.  But the rejection still stung.  My latest collection was rejected by another magazine, but to be fair, it was my first submission and I could tell after looking at it again that they just couldn’t see what I was trying to convey from the package.  My fault.  My submission to knitty?… well done, beautifully photographed (Amy made sure to point that out), but still rejected.  The issue?…no one is making handknit ties for little boys and most little boys aren’t wearing ties, lol. 

    It’s all been a slow process filled with fear, doubt, despair, joy, elevation, excitement, and project-stalking :)  I only manage to continue because of designers like yourself who inspire me, and who occasionally publish posts like this one, which lets me know that I’m not alone and that it’s normal to feel this way.  I know I’ll be on THAT level some day, and I’ll keep plugging along submitting patterns, and self-publishing the ones I really love.  And I’ll remember posts like this one when I start feeling down and wondering if I shouldn’t go back to working in a bank somewhere :)

  • Chantelle

    Hi sweetie,

    I can relate to so much of what you have said.  If there is one piece of advice I can give it is this: even when you are doubting yourself, when that nasty little voice tells you that your work is not good enough then remember there are so many people who believe in you and who love your work.

    Designing, like all forms of creativity, is so bound up in who you are which is why any rejection is so very painful (perhaps it feels like a rejection, not only of your work, but also of you?).  Unfortunately, that’s the deal with this line of work.  However, it is so very much worth it, hun, when the fruits of your labours are accepted.  I’ve seen your tweets and FB statuses when one of your patterns is going to be published.  It seems to make you so very, very happy.When you have those dark days, when the clouds loom, remember the feeling of acceptance and use it to help buoy you up.

    Don’t stop stretching your abilities with your more out-of-this-world ideas; if they don’t get accepted then perhaps then still get them out onto paper and maybe self-publish them.  You might as well make them available as I am sure people will buy them – it’s better than hiding them away for good.  It’s just something to think about, I guess.

    I love your designs, and I know that many others feel that way about your work, too.  You have a gift, Ruth.  Always remember that xxx

  • http://beckyinvt.wordpress.com/ BeckyinVT

    I’d send it in, some of my best acceptances have been my second or third choice on the submission, but they worked best when the editor was looking at the collection!

    I also do what Kate is describing. If I like an idea I’ll send it out 4 or 5 or 6 times EXACTLY the way it is until it finds a good home. I only revamp if I look at it upon rejection (that time away from the idea can be so helpful) and think to myself, geeze, why didn’t I see this problem before? Then I tweak the idea and keep it on hand for the next design call it fits into.

  • http://www.brandigirlblog.com/ Brandi

    I don’t know if the question of your abilities will ever go away; I deal with the same feelings and wonder the same things. But my experience has told me that I can let the self-doubt swamp me into submission, or I can choose to see that questioning as a good thing. 

    I try to think of it this way – the questioning can be a critical voice or a critiquing voice – the first is harsh and hard and just wants to put me down; the second may be hard to hear, but is ultimately looking for places I can improve on. I try to remind myself to critique, not criticize when the questioning voice comes in. I can’t say that every time I manage to pull myself up out of that spiral, because that’s just flat out not true. But I do want to say that you’re not alone when you feel that way.

    True story – I never sold a single piece of jewelry before I opened my shop. I had shop owners turn their noses up, I had potential buyers tell me they could make what I do. I never sold a single piece of jewelry until I opened my online shop. That first sale was so gratifying, and every sale was amazing. But I still had detractors tell me things I should change (most usually the price), and it took me a while to realize that my work isn’t for everyone. Once I got clear on that, the snide words or rejections stopped bothering me quite so much.

  • Pingback: The Big D « Tasteful Diversions

  • Pingback: Luck, determination, hard work » rock + purl - clever, elegant and modern designs

  • Pingback: All revved up » rock + purl - clever, elegant and modern designs